Risky Shot by Joe Root Splits Opinion as England Collapse in India Test
The unorthodox dismissal of Joe Root in the third Test against India has sparked debate, highlighting the contrasting views on England’s aggressive “Bazball” approach.
Batting at 18 with England well-placed at 224-2, Root attempted a switch-hit off Jasprit Bumrah, only to edge it to Yashasvi Jaiswal for a stunning catch.
This dismissal triggered a dramatic collapse, as England were bowled out for 319, adding to Root’s woes in the series where he averages just 14.
Sunil Gavaskar lauded Jaiswal’s “unbelievable” catch, attributing its difficulty to the unique trajectory created by the switch-hit. He pointed out the challenge for fielders to adjust their focus when facing the bat face instead of the back.
Former England opener Nick Knight acknowledged Root’s frustration, suggesting he felt he could have easily converted the ball for four. He questioned the timing of the shot considering England’s positive position and cautioned against forcing the aggressive style.
Media personality Piers Morgan defended the “Bazball” philosophy, arguing that fans should embrace its inherent risks and thrilling nature. He criticized those criticizing Root for his aggressive shot selection.
However, former England captain Michael Vaughan strongly disagreed, calling Morgan’s comments “utter rubbish.” He argued that Root gifted India a cheap wicket at a crucial juncture, highlighting the importance of adapting playing style to the situation.
Vaughan expressed frustration with England’s overall performance, stating they “wasted a huge opportunity.”
Root could have been more cautious with his shot selection in the initial phase of the third day’s game. The bowlers were fresh, and India had already lost ten wickets, including a match-winning bowler.
Once Jasprit Bumrah’s spell had concluded, Root could have felt more at ease to assert himself. However, attempting something against one of the world’s best bowlers seemed like a rash decision, especially considering Bumrah’s consistent pressure throughout the series.
“Wrong shot at the wrong moment” sums up Root’s faltered switch hit. Perhaps he doesn’t need to adhere strictly to the Bazball philosophy. Enjoying the game while relying on capable teammates to inflict damage could be a better approach.
Test cricket is a lengthy affair, and England now finds themselves in a precarious position. As they continue to bowl on the fourth day of the test, it’s evident which side holds the upper hand in the game.
With the series tied 1-1, the debate surrounding “Bazball” and individual shot selection is likely to continue as the action unfolds in the remaining Tests.
