Pakistan’s Test Struggles Highlight Lack of Intent and Strategy
In the aftermath of Pakistan’s heavy defeat to England by an innings and 47 runs, despite scoring over 550 runs in the first innings, questions are being raised about the team’s mindset and strategy. During the post-match conference, Pakistan’s approach to the game was scrutinized. Despite piling up a massive total, they failed to capitalize on it, allowing England to find a way to win.
The Pakistani team’s first innings, which lasted nearly two days, was seen as a passive display of cricket. Their inability to push for a commanding lead or apply pressure on England reflected a “safety-first” mentality. This mindset, which prioritized avoiding risks, ultimately backfired as England mounted an aggressive response. After losing Ollie Pope early, England kept their focus on winning, with a clear plan to wear Pakistan down. In contrast, Pakistan’s defense-first approach left them vulnerable, and as fatigue set in on day four, the team collapsed under pressure.
View this post on Instagram
The tactical contrast between the two teams was evident. England batted with intent, even under pressure, while Pakistan seemed unsure of how to use their substantial total. As England’s run rate increased session by session, Pakistan struggled in the extreme heat, leading to their eventual downfall.
Pakistan’s middle-order woes were a central point of criticism. The team has struggled with consistency, and key players like Babar Azam and Mohammad Rizwan have not delivered in crucial moments. Rizwan’s decent performances against Bangladesh did little to change the team’s overall fortunes. The lack of intent, particularly in the middle order, has become a glaring weakness.
The team’s struggles were further illustrated by individual failures. Abdullah Shafiq’s dismissal in the second innings was described as a result of poor decision-making, while Sam Ayub’s shot selection was seen as reckless under pressure. England’s bowlers deliberately baited the Pakistani batters into taking unnecessary risks, knowing that breaking their defenses on a flat track would be tough.
With Pakistan having failed to win a Test match at home in the past two years, calls for change are growing louder. The team needs fresh talent, particularly from domestic cricket, where players have shown the patience and mental toughness required for the longest format of the game. Test cricket demands strategic thinking and adaptability across sessions, something Pakistan has lacked. In contrast, England’s ability to turn the game around by scoring more than 180 runs in a single session exemplified the difference in approach.
To turn things around, Pakistan must reconsider their team selection. Non-performers should be dropped, even if only temporarily, to allow them to reflect on their form and fitness. The physical conditioning of the players has also come under question, with many struggling to cope with the challenging conditions. For Pakistan to compete at the highest level, every player must give 100% at all times, and right now, they seem far from that standard.
Pakistan’s inability to take control of matches, even when posting huge totals, reveals deep-seated issues in the team’s approach. Without a shift in mentality and some strategic changes, their struggles in Test cricket are likely to continue.
