England in Crisis: Bairstow Not Good Enough for These Conditions but Baz Backs Him for Ranchi Test
England’s resounding 434-run defeat in the third Test against India at Rajkot has left them staring down a 2-1 deficit in the five-match series. As they head to Ranchi for the fourth Test, several crucial questions hang over Ben Stokes’ men, with the form of opener Jonny Bairstow sparking the most debate.
While Joe Root’s shot selection faced criticism after his first-innings dismissal, Bairstow’s struggles have become a major concern. He managed only four runs in Rajkot, taking his series average to a meager 17.
He also holds the unwanted record of eight ducks against India in Tests, with his first-innings dismissal in Rajkot marking another instance.
Former England captain Alastair Cook believes it’s time to give Bairstow a rest. “He’s had a tough tour,” Cook noted, pushing for Bairstow’s replacement with Essex’s Dan Lawrence, highlighting his “fresh” perspective.
However, others advocate for continued support. Nasser Hussain argues that “everything they’ve done is about giving their players security,” and Bairstow’s experience shouldn’t be overlooked.
Head coach Brendon McCullum shares this sentiment, stating that they “know a top-quality Jonny Bairstow is as good as anyone,” and will stick to their backing despite the current slump.
The decision regarding Bairstow’s inclusion in the Ranchi Test will be a significant one. Dropping him sends a message of accountability but risks disrupting the team’s newfound confidence in backing individual talent.
Conversely, retaining him signifies unwavering faith but carries the burden of continued underperformance.
Ultimately, the choice rests with Stokes and his management. Whether they opt for a fresh start with Lawrence or continue to invest in Bairstow’s revival will shape the narrative of England’s fightback in the remaining Tests.
For now, it doesn’t look like Bairstow will be replaced because Baz has said, “I don’t have concerns over him. I’m not blind but he’s done so well for us and he’s had such an impactful career.”
“So from our point of view, we’ve got to keep on giving him confidence and block out a lot of the external noise as well and keep him really present and focused on what he’s trying to achieve, and I’m sure Jonny will come good.”
The Ranchi selection will be closely watched, not just for its impact on the series but also as a signal of England’s long-term batting vision.
